
Hey y’all. Come on up, grab something warm to drink, and come sit a spell. We’ve got something to talk about today.
Marriage.
Now, there’s a subject that can get people worked up faster than somebody bringing store-bought potato salad to a family reunion and passing it off as homemade.
We’re going to talk about religion, the Constitution, the federal government, a woman I’ll call Jane, four couples who fought for their families, and something called the Defense of Marriage Act.
We’re also going to talk about Dorfs and Wimbleys.
Don’t worry. We’ll get there.
A Conversation I Never Forgot
Somewhere around 2009 or 2010, I had a conversation with a woman I’ll call Jane.
I liked Jane. She had a sweet spirit, and I enjoyed her company. Her faith was an important part of her life.
I don’t consider myself Christian, but I’ve never believed that people need to share my religious views, or lack thereof, for us to get along.
Goddess knows, Billie and I don’t agree on everything. Neither do my friends and I.
My general philosophy is pretty simple: You do you, Boo.
As long as we’re talking about consenting adults, I figure people ought to have considerable freedom to live their lives without somebody else standing over them explaining why they’re doing it wrong.
I try not to yuck somebody else’s yum.
Now, if you’re twenty-something and running around in near-freezing temperatures wearing an outfit that leaves very little to the imagination, I might suggest you go home and put some damn clothes on.
But that’s mostly because I’m cold just looking at you.
Anyway.
Jane and I got into a conversation about same-sex marriage.
She believed marriage was a religious institution, reserved for a man and a woman. Same-sex couples, she argued, could have civil unions. They simply shouldn’t call those relationships marriages or expect the same rights and protections that came with what she considered a God-given marriage.
And that’s where I got stuck.
Not because Jane believed marriage was sacred. She was certainly entitled to that belief.
But because she believed her religious understanding of marriage should determine how everyone else’s relationships were recognized under the law.
I asked why.
If marriage belonged exclusively to religion, what about people who weren’t religious? What about couples who married before a judge or at a courthouse? What about people whose faith traditions were different from hers?
People had been getting married long before Christianity existed.
Surely marriage wasn’t suddenly invented when somebody built a church.
And if two women or two men were making the same commitment to each other that a heterosexual couple made, why should they have to call it something different?
A civil union, perhaps.
But then what?
Would they introduce their partners as their husbands and wives? Or would those words be reserved for the people who had proper marriages?
Would we need an entirely new vocabulary?
“This is my Dorf.”
“Your what?”
“My Dorf. We’ve been Wimbled for twelve years.”
“Oh! Congratulations! Was it a lovely Wimbling?”
“Beautiful. We had a licensed Wimbler and everything.”
I have absolutely no idea where Dorf and Wimbley came from. They apparently wandered into my brain uninvited and decided to stay.
But the absurdity illustrates something that bothered me then and still bothers me now.
Why should one couple be required to explain that their relationship belongs in a different category when another couple can simply say, “This is my wife”?
And more importantly, why should that different category come with fewer rights?
Because that’s where the conversation became something much bigger than vocabulary.
We weren’t merely discussing what to call a relationship. We were discussing what protections people should receive because of it.
At some point, I also brought up the teachings attributed to Jesus. You know, the ones about loving your neighbor, caring for the sick, welcoming strangers, and showing compassion to people society overlooks.
I wasn’t trying to tell Jane how to practice her religion. I was questioning how denying other people equal treatment fit with those teachings.
That didn’t go over particularly well.
Jane responded with anger and resentment. I wasn’t angry with her, but I was disappointed that my questions had been received that way.
I continued reaching out afterward, but eventually the welcome disappeared.
And that was a shame, because I genuinely liked her.
Still, the conversation stayed with me because it raised a question I couldn’t shake.
Who gets to decide what marriage means when the government is the one handing out the legal protections?
To understand why that question mattered so much in 2009 or 2010, we need to go back a little further.
Marriage Was Here Long Before the Church
Let’s clear up one misconception right away.
Marriage did not originate with Christianity.
Marriage arrangements existed in ancient Mesopotamia, Egypt, Greece, Rome, and many other societies thousands of years ago. Their purposes and forms varied considerably.
Some involved religious rituals. Others centered on families, property, inheritance, alliances, or obligations between households.
And no, these weren’t necessarily modern marriages built around romantic love, equal partnership, or individual choice.
History is rarely that tidy.
Marriage has meant different things to different people in different places, and the institution has changed repeatedly.
Christian churches eventually developed their own theological understandings and ceremonies surrounding marriage. Within Catholic tradition, marriage came to be understood as a sacrament. Other Christian denominations developed different approaches.
But the existence of religious marriage doesn’t mean every marriage is religious.
In the United States, couples can marry in a church, a synagogue, a mosque, a courthouse, a garden, or somebody’s backyard.
They can be married by a religious officiant or, where authorized by law, a civil official.
They can believe their marriage is blessed by God.
They can believe it is a sacred covenant.
Or they can believe it is a deeply personal commitment between two people who have decided to build a life together.
The government doesn’t require couples to share a theology.
What it does require is compliance with the civil laws governing marriage.
And once a marriage is legally recognized, it can carry consequences involving property, taxation, inheritance, insurance, parental responsibilities, medical decision-making, immigration, and survivor benefits.
Those protections don’t materialize because somebody said a prayer.
They exist because of laws, contracts, and government recognition.
Which brings me back to something I wish I’d said to Jane.
GOD DOESN’T GIVE YOU INSURANCE, JANE! YOUR DORF’S JOB DOES!
Well, sometimes. Assuming the employer offers the coverage and the plan allows it.
We do have to be accurate.
But you get my point.
A religious blessing is one thing. Eligibility for an employer’s family health plan is another.
And for years, federal law deliberately treated certain marriages differently from others.
The Constitution Had Something to Say About Marriage
Before we get to 1996, let’s visit 1967.
That year, the United States Supreme Court decided Loving v. Virginia.
Richard and Mildred Loving were an interracial couple who had married in Washington, D.C., in 1958. When they returned to Virginia, where interracial marriage was prohibited, they were arrested.
Think about that.
Two people had legally married, and their home state treated their marriage as a crime.
The Supreme Court unanimously struck down Virginia’s interracial-marriage prohibition.
The Court recognized marriage as a fundamental right and held that the state’s racial restrictions violated the Fourteenth Amendment.
That amendment contains one of the most important phrases in American constitutional law:
“Equal protection of the laws.”
Not equal protection for people whose neighbors approve of them.
Not equal protection for people who belong to a particular church.
Equal protection.
Loving didn’t decide the question of same-sex marriage, but it established an important foundation: marriage was a civil institution subject to constitutional protections, not merely a religious matter.
There is another distinction worth knowing.
The Fourteenth Amendment directly restricts state governments. The Fifth Amendment’s Due Process Clause has been interpreted to impose equal-protection principles on the federal government.
That’s important because the Defense of Marriage Act was federal legislation.
Those constitutional principles would eventually become central to the battles that followed.
1996: Congress Decides Which Marriages Count
In 1996, Congress passed the Defense of Marriage Act, commonly called DOMA.
President Bill Clinton signed it into law on September 21.
The legislation passed with overwhelming bipartisan support. The House approved it 342–67, and the Senate approved it 85–14.
This wasn’t a fringe proposal slipping quietly through Congress. It reflected a broad political consensus at the time.
And here’s something many people don’t realize.
When DOMA passed, not one U.S. state had legalized same-sex marriage.
Congress was acting in anticipation of something that might happen.
A legal challenge in Hawaii had raised the possibility that the state might eventually allow same-sex couples to marry. That possibility prompted fears that other states, and the federal government, might be required to recognize those marriages.
So Congress acted.
DOMA had two particularly important provisions.
Section 2 purported to allow states to refuse recognition of same-sex marriages performed in other states.
Section 3 established a federal definition of marriage as a union between one man and one woman, and defined a spouse in opposite-sex terms.
That meant that even if a state recognized a same-sex couple as legally married, the federal government would not.
Imagine being married when you walked into your state courthouse but unmarried when you filed your federal taxes.
Married when you spoke to your neighbors.
Unmarried when you dealt with Social Security.
Married according to the state that issued your license.
Unmarried according to Washington.
It wasn’t simply confusing.
It had consequences.
And those consequences were borne by real people.
“Just Call It a Civil Union”
This is where Jane’s argument comes back into the picture.
Why couldn’t same-sex couples simply have civil unions?
Well, in some states, they could.
Vermont established civil unions in 2000, providing same-sex couples with many of the state-level rights and responsibilities of marriage.
Other states eventually developed domestic-partnership or civil-union systems of their own.
But those arrangements weren’t uniform, and they weren’t necessarily recognized outside the state that created them.
Most importantly, they didn’t overcome DOMA.
A state could provide extensive legal protections to a couple and still be unable to make the federal government treat them as married.
In 2004, the Government Accountability Office identified 1,138 federal statutory provisions in which marital status affected rights, benefits, or responsibilities.
That doesn’t mean every married couple automatically received 1,138 benefits.
It means that marriage mattered throughout federal law.
And calling a relationship something else could leave couples outside those provisions.
So when somebody said, “They can have civil unions,” the next question needed to be:
Will they have the same legal protections?
If the answer was no, we weren’t discussing two different words for the same thing.
We were discussing two different classes of legal recognition.
And if the answer was yes, we still had a reasonable question to ask.
Why insist that one group use a different word?
Why should one couple be married while another was Wimbled?
Let’s meet some of the people who discovered what those distinctions meant in practice.
Edie and Thea: Forty-Four Years Together
Edith Windsor and Thea Spyer met in New York in the 1960s.
They fell in love, built a life together, and became engaged in 1967.
But theirs wasn’t an engagement that could end with an ordinary trip to the courthouse.
For decades, marriage wasn’t legally available to them.
Thea was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis, a progressive disease that increasingly affected her mobility and health.
Edie remained beside her.
They shared a home, a life, and the ordinary responsibilities of a long partnership.
In 2007, after more than four decades together, they traveled to Toronto and married.
Two years later, Thea died.
She left her estate to Edie.
New York recognized their marriage, but the federal government did not.
Because of DOMA, Thea’s estate could not receive the federal estate-tax marital deduction available to qualifying surviving spouses in opposite-sex marriages.
The resulting federal estate-tax liability was $363,053.
Let that sink in.
After forty-four years together, after caring for her partner through serious illness, after finally being able to marry the woman she loved, Edie lost Thea.
And then the federal government treated her as though their marriage didn’t count.
Edie challenged the law and sought a refund.
Her case, United States v. Windsor, reached the Supreme Court.
On June 26, 2013, the Court ruled that DOMA’s federal definition of marriage was unconstitutional.
Edie won.
But Thea wasn’t there to celebrate with her.
That’s something I think we sometimes lose when we discuss landmark Supreme Court cases.
We remember the decision.
We remember the date.
We remember the constitutional principle.
But the people who fought those battles had already lived through the consequences.
For Edie, it was never just an abstract argument about federalism or equal protection.
It was about the woman she had loved for forty-four years.
Karen and Amy: The Insurance Problem
Now let’s talk about health insurance.
Karen Golinski was an attorney employed by the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.
She and her partner, Amy Cunninghis, had been together for more than twenty years when they married in California in August 2008.
They were raising a son.
Karen had a federal job, and that job came with access to the Federal Employees Health Benefits Program.
After marrying Amy, Karen applied to enroll her wife in her family health plan.
The request was denied.
Not because Amy wasn’t her spouse under California law.
Not because Karen lacked qualifying employment.
But because the federal government, applying DOMA, refused to recognize their marriage.
And here’s something that makes the story even more frustrating.
According to Karen’s legal filings, she was paying the full family rate for coverage, but her plan covered only herself and their son.
Amy wasn’t included.
The family had to purchase separate insurance for Amy, with less comprehensive coverage than the plan Karen could have provided through her employment.
This wasn’t merely an argument over what appeared on an insurance card.
It meant additional expense, less protection, and uncertainty about what might happen if Amy became seriously ill.
Karen challenged the denial through the federal judiciary’s employment-discrimination process.
The Ninth Circuit’s chief judge ordered that Amy be enrolled, but the federal Office of Personnel Management intervened, relying on DOMA.
Think about how extraordinary that is.
A woman working for the federal court system had to fight the federal government to have her legally married wife treated as a spouse for employment benefits.
In February 2012, a federal district court ruled in Karen’s favor and prohibited officials from interfering with Amy’s enrollment.
In March, the Office of Personnel Management instructed the insurance carrier to enroll Amy.
That was an important victory.
But the litigation wasn’t finished.
The ruling was appealed, and the appeals remained pending until the Supreme Court decided Windsor in June 2013.
Following that decision, the parties agreed the appeals should be dismissed. The Ninth Circuit dismissed them in July 2013.
The federal government’s 2012 enrollment instruction applied to Karen and Amy’s particular case. It did not immediately open the same coverage to every other married same-sex federal employee.
So even after Karen won, other families were still waiting.
And this is why I get a little worked up when someone tells me marriage is exclusively a religious matter.
Because God wasn’t reviewing Karen’s enrollment paperwork.
A government-administered benefits system was.
Karen wasn’t asking a church to approve her relationship.
She was asking her employer’s health plan to recognize her wife.
And DOMA stood in the way.
Bradford and Anthony: A Marriage That Couldn’t Keep Them Together
Bradford Wells was an American citizen living in San Francisco.
His husband, Anthony John Makk, was Australian.
They met in Sydney while Bradford was on vacation.
They fell in love and built a life together.
In 2004, when Massachusetts began allowing same-sex couples to marry, Bradford asked Anthony to marry him.
They married that year.
By 2011, they had been together for approximately nineteen years.
Bradford had serious health problems associated with AIDS, and Anthony was his primary caregiver.
He helped Bradford get out of bed on difficult mornings, prepared meals, assisted with medications, and handled tasks that Bradford couldn’t always manage alone.
Their life wasn’t some abstract political argument.
It was two people caring for each other.
And then the federal government told them their marriage didn’t count for immigration purposes.
Anthony had applied for permanent residency based on his marriage to Bradford.
The application was denied in 2011 because DOMA prevented federal immigration authorities from recognizing Bradford as his qualifying spouse.
Anthony was told to leave the United States.
Bradford faced losing the person who cared for him.
In an August 2011 CNN interview, Bradford explained that Anthony was his only caregiver in San Francisco. His family lived elsewhere, and he didn’t know how he would manage if Anthony had to leave.
Anthony explained that moving to Australia wasn’t a simple alternative.
Bradford’s doctors, medical support, and health insurance were established in the United States. Relocating a seriously ill person meant disrupting all of that.
And when asked whether they had failed to meet any immigration requirements other than being a same-sex couple, Anthony said they had met the other requirements.
Now imagine that for a moment.
You’re seriously ill.
Your spouse helps you get through the day.
And your government says that, for immigration purposes, the two of you aren’t really married.
A similarly situated heterosexual American citizen could petition for a foreign-born spouse.
Bradford could not.
In January 2012, Anthony received a two-year reprieve from removal.
It meant he could remain with Bradford for the time being.
But a reprieve wasn’t the same thing as having their marriage recognized for immigration purposes.
That fundamental barrier remained until the federal legal landscape changed following Windsor in 2013.
And here’s what I keep coming back to.
Bradford and Anthony weren’t asking the government to create a relationship between them.
They already had one.
They weren’t asking a church to perform a ceremony.
They were already married.
They were asking the government not to separate them because it refused to recognize that marriage.
Tell me again how this was just about a word.
Tracey and Maggie: A Veteran’s Wife
Tracey Cooper-Harris served twelve years in the United States Army.
Her service included deployments connected to military operations in Iraq and Afghanistan.
She received numerous medals and commendations and was honorably discharged.
After leaving the military, Tracey dealt with serious service-connected health conditions, including multiple sclerosis and post-traumatic stress disorder.
She married Maggie Cooper-Harris in California in 2008.
Maggie helped care for her.
According to the couple’s court filings, Maggie accompanied Tracey to medical appointments, helped monitor her health, and comforted her when PTSD-related nightmares interrupted her sleep.
Those are the kinds of things spouses do.
They show up.
They help.
They stay.
Because Tracey’s disabilities were connected to her military service, she received disability compensation through the Department of Veterans Affairs.
She sought recognition of Maggie as her spouse for veterans’ benefits.
The VA refused.
And here’s an important legal distinction.
Their case involved not just DOMA, but also separate provisions of federal veterans’ benefits law that defined spouses and surviving spouses in opposite-sex terms.
Even if DOMA’s general federal marriage definition were removed, those separate restrictions still presented a barrier.
That meant Tracey and Maggie had to challenge more than one law.
The denial affected additional disability compensation available to qualifying married veterans and legal protections associated with surviving spouses.
Tracey had served her country.
She had fulfilled the obligations of military service.
But when she sought the legal recognition available to married veterans, the federal government told her that Maggie didn’t qualify as her wife.
The couple filed suit in 2012.
On August 29, 2013, a federal district court ruled that the challenged exclusions violated constitutional equal-protection principles.
The Department of Justice subsequently informed Congress that it would not appeal that ruling.
Additional proceedings continued into 2014 before the case closed.
Their legal battle illustrates something important about the aftermath of Windsor.
Striking down DOMA’s general federal definition didn’t automatically erase every separate federal restriction written into other laws.
Those provisions also had to be addressed.
And it raises a question worth sitting with.
What does it mean to thank someone for their service while denying their family protections that other veterans’ families receive?
Tracey wasn’t asking for a special privilege.
She was asking for the legal recognition of her spouse.
Four Couples. Four Different Battles.
An estate-tax bill. A denied insurance policy. The threat of deportation. Veterans’ benefits withheld.
Four couples, four different battles, and one common thread: the federal government refused to recognize their marriages.
None of them was asking a church to change its beliefs. They were asking their government to recognize their families and provide the same legal protections available to other married couples.
That’s an entirely different question.
The Country Begins to Change
In 2004, Massachusetts became the first U.S. state to allow same-sex couples to marry.
Other states followed, although the process was uneven and frequently contentious.
California briefly allowed same-sex marriage in 2008 before voters approved Proposition 8, which halted new same-sex marriages until subsequent court rulings restored the right.
When Jane and I had our conversation around 2009 or 2010, this debate was happening everywhere.
In legislatures.
In courtrooms.
In churches.
Around kitchen tables.
And apparently between two women who had very different ideas about whether the government should be in the business of enforcing a religious definition of marriage.
Public opinion was changing, but it hadn’t yet reached majority support in many national surveys.
According to Pew Research Center’s polling, support for legal same-sex marriage stood at 37 percent in 2009 and 42 percent in 2010.
The country was in the middle of a substantial shift.
And the courts were about to change the legal landscape.
2013: The Federal Government Must Recognize the Marriage
On June 26, 2013, the Supreme Court decided United States v. Windsor.
The Court struck down Section 3 of DOMA, holding that the federal government’s refusal to recognize lawful same-sex marriages violated constitutional protections of liberty and equality under the Fifth Amendment.
That decision mattered far beyond Edie Windsor’s estate-tax bill.
It changed how the federal government could treat legally married same-sex couples.
But it didn’t yet require every state to allow same-sex couples to marry.
That question remained.
2015: The Right to Marry
Two years later, on June 26, 2015, the Supreme Court decided Obergefell v. Hodges.
The Court held that the Fourteenth Amendment requires states to license marriages between same-sex couples and recognize lawful same-sex marriages performed elsewhere.
The decision rested on the constitutional protections of due process and equal protection.
It was a historic change.
But I want to be careful about what the decision did and did not mean.
It did not require churches to change their religious doctrines.
It did not require religious officiants to perform a same-sex wedding contrary to their beliefs.
It did not erase religious disagreement about marriage.
People remained free to hold their beliefs.
What changed was the government’s obligation to provide civil marriage on equal constitutional terms.
And that distinction is essential.
Religious freedom protects your right to practice your faith. It doesn’t automatically give you the right to make your faith the law for everyone else.
2022: Congress Revisits Marriage
The story didn’t end in 2015.
In 2022, Congress passed the Respect for Marriage Act, which President Joe Biden signed into law on December 13.
The legislation formally repealed DOMA.
It established federal recognition of qualifying marriages and protections for interstate recognition of marriages validly performed under state law.
It also included protections for religious liberty.
And here’s an interesting development.
The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints publicly supported the legislative approach taken in the Respect for Marriage Act.
The Church did not change its doctrine defining marriage as between a man and a woman.
But it supported a framework intended to protect religious freedom while respecting the legal rights of LGBTQ couples.
I find that distinction meaningful.
A religious institution can maintain its beliefs about sacred marriage while accepting that civil law recognizes marriages outside its religious definition.
Those positions are not necessarily incompatible.
There is one important limitation to the Respect for Marriage Act, though.
It does not independently require every state to issue new same-sex marriage licenses if Obergefell were ever overturned.
The Supreme Court’s constitutional ruling remains essential to that nationwide requirement.
So the legal story is not quite as simple as saying the issue was settled forever.
What Would Jesus Do?
I suppose we should return to the part of my conversation with Jane that didn’t go particularly well.
I don’t identify as Christian.
I attended Bible school when I was younger, and while it’s been a long time, I do remember some things.
I remember teachings about feeding the hungry.
Caring for the sick.
Welcoming strangers.
Showing mercy.
Loving your neighbor.
And not being so busy inspecting the speck in somebody else’s eye that you overlook the plank in your own.
Now, I recognize that Christians disagree about how those teachings apply to marriage and sexuality.
Some believe marriage must remain between a man and a woman because of their understanding of scripture.
Others believe affirming same-sex marriages is consistent with the Christian obligation to love and respect one’s neighbors.
Those are genuine theological differences.
But the question I asked Jane wasn’t whether she had the right to believe what she believed.
Of course she did.
My question was why her beliefs should determine the legal protections available to someone who didn’t share them.
And I still think that’s a fair question.
Because you don’t have to agree with someone else’s choices to recognize that they are entitled to dignity.
You don’t have to share their faith.
You don’t have to understand their relationship.
You don’t even have to particularly like them.
Civil rights aren’t supposed to be a reward for being approved of by your neighbors.
What I Remember About Jane
I’ve thought about that conversation from time to time over the years.
Not because I was angry. I wasn’t.
And not because I expect everyone I know to agree with me. They don’t.
I liked Jane, and I remember her with affection.
What disappointed me was how the questions themselves became the problem.
I challenged her reasoning. She responded with anger and resentment.
I kept reaching out afterward, but eventually the welcome disappeared.
And that was sad.
We don’t have to agree about everything to remain friends. But we do have to make room for the possibility that someone might question what we believe.
Questions aren’t necessarily attacks.
Sometimes they’re invitations to think.
Sometimes they’re opportunities to explain ourselves.
And sometimes they reveal that we haven’t examined an assumption quite as closely as we thought we had.
Which brings us right back to this month’s theme.
You don’t know what you don’t know.
In 1996, many Americans believed they were defending the institution of marriage.
Others believed the law was denying equal recognition to families whose commitments were no less real.
As the years passed, the country heard more stories.
Stories about widows, parents, people caring for sick spouses, veterans, and families facing separation.
And gradually, more Americans began reconsidering what they thought they knew.
That doesn’t mean everyone reached the same religious conclusion.
It means the legal and public conversation changed.
The Right to Be Different
There’s something that strikes me about the four couples we’ve met today.
Edie and Thea didn’t need anyone to tell them whether their forty-four years together had meaning.
Karen and Amy didn’t need a stranger’s permission to raise their family.
Bradford and Anthony didn’t need someone else’s religious approval to care for each other.
Tracey and Maggie didn’t need a church to decide whether their commitment was worthy of recognition.
They knew who they were to one another.
What they needed was for the law to stop treating their families as less deserving of recognition.
And I keep coming back to the distinction Jane and I couldn’t seem to resolve.
A church has the right to define marriage according to its faith.
A person has the right to believe marriage is sacred.
But a civil marriage is also a legal relationship, with responsibilities and protections created and recognized by government.
Those aren’t the same thing.
The Constitution doesn’t promise that every person will always receive identical treatment in every circumstance. But its guarantees of liberty and equal protection place real limits on how government can exclude people from fundamental rights.
And in the context of marriage, the Supreme Court eventually recognized that those protections extend to same-sex couples.
You know, I don’t particularly care whether you call your partner your husband, your wife, your spouse, your sweetheart, or your Dorf.
If the two of you want to have a Wimbling in the backyard with a licensed Wimbler, I’ll bring a covered dish.
But if you’re legally married, I believe your marriage should receive the same civil recognition as anyone else’s.
Because here’s what I believed when Jane and I had that conversation, and what I still believe today:
You don’t have to believe as I believe, love as I love, or live as I live for me to believe you deserve the same protections under the law.
And I think that’s worth remembering.
Y’all come sit a spell.
Author’s note: Jane is a pseudonym used to protect the privacy of someone I once knew. Our conversation is reconstructed from memory.
Sources and Further Reading
Primary legislation and Supreme Court decisions
- Defense of Marriage Act, Public Law 104-199 (1996). U.S. Government Publishing Office.
https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/PLAW-104publ199/html/PLAW-104publ199.htm - U.S. Senate Roll Call Vote 280, September 10, 1996.
https://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_votes/vote1042/vote_104_2_00280.htm - Loving v. Virginia, 388 U.S. 1 (1967).
https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/388/1/ - United States v. Windsor, 570 U.S. 744 (2013).
https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/12-307 - Obergefell v. Hodges, 576 U.S. 644 (2015).
https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/14-556 - Respect for Marriage Act, Public Law 117-228 (2022).
https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/PLAW-117publ228/html/PLAW-117publ228.htm
Federal benefits and public opinion
- U.S. Government Accountability Office. Defense of Marriage Act: Update to Prior Report, GAO-04-353R (2004).
https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-04-353r - Pew Research Center. Historical public opinion research on same-sex marriage.
https://www.pewresearch.org/
The couples and their cases
- Edith Windsor and Thea Spyer: United States v. Windsor, 570 U.S. 744 (2013).
https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/12-307 - Karen Golinski and Amy Cunninghis: Golinski v. U.S. Office of Personnel Management, 824 F. Supp. 2d 968 (N.D. Cal. 2012), and the Ninth Circuit’s July 2013 dismissal of the appeals.
https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca9/12-15388/12-15388-2013-07-23.html - Karen Golinski and Amy Cunninghis: Plaintiff’s appellate brief (2012). Lambda Legal.
https://lambdalegal.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/golinski_us_20120703_plaintiff-appellees-answer-brief.pdf - Bradford Wells and Anthony John Makk: CNN interview transcript, August 10, 2011.
https://prod.transcripts.cnn.com/show/cnr/date/2011-08-10/segment/06 - Bradford Wells and Anthony John Makk: KQED, Deportation Stayed for Same-Sex Partner, January 6, 2012.
https://www.kqed.org/news/52429/deportation-stayed-for-same-sex-partner - Tracey and Maggie Cooper-Harris: Cooper-Harris v. United States, 965 F. Supp. 2d 1139 (C.D. Cal. 2013), and subsequent proceedings. Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse, University of Michigan.
https://clearinghouse.net/case/12582/ - Tracey and Maggie Cooper-Harris: U.S. Department of Justice letter to the Speaker of the House, October 22, 2013.
https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/oip/legacy/2014/07/23/10-22-2013.pdf
Religious perspectives
- The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Statement on the United States Congress Respect for Marriage Act, November 15, 2022.
https://newsroom.churchofjesuschrist.org/article/respect-for-marriage-act-statement - The Bible: Matthew 7:1–5; Matthew 22:36–40; Matthew 25:35–40; Luke 10:25–37; John 13:34–35.

Leave a Reply